Discussion and Logic (and lack thereof)

discussion, logic, student ministry and evangelism

This is a repost from a blog post of the same name.

Last night I went to Skinner's Pub with a few friends. We talked about politics and religion - oh, and the thread count of our sheets. We had some great conversation. One of my friends (he considers himself an unbeliever) said that one of the reasons he has a lot of trouble with Christianity is the lack of logic. He said that he finds it nearly impossible to follow many Christian's theology in a logical manner.

The sad thing is that I didn't even feel the urge to correct him. To be honest, I agreed with him very enthusiastically. A lot of effort is required to develop theology that explains how scripture is analyzed (is it literal, figurative, for a people that are not us, for us or inspirational) and to be able to explain the picture we have of God and what that means for us today.

So I wonder if we encourage each other to examine our faith enough. Do we take opportunities (at the bar or any other "unconventional" place) to discuss what we claim to believe? Are we willing enough to admit if something we believe doesn't quite hold up?

Just Some Lutheran Guy

I have been both a guy and Lutheran as long as I can remember (anything before about five or six, I just have to take my parents word for). My wife and I live in South Dakota. I work a regular job and volunteer at my church in the Young Adult/Emerging Adult area of ministry. I plan to attend seminary down the road and enjoy writing.


Comments

groveyp's picture

I really like this point of

I really like this point of view. That is true. Are we willing to ask hard questions about the faith? Are we willing to confront questions that we don't know the answers to?

Nathan Cornett Director of Online Training, Called to Youth Ministry
Tel: 619-823-5974
nathan@calledtoyouthministry.com | www.calledtoyouthministry.com
 

Chris Rollman's picture

I think I agree with your

I think I agree with your thought here and also disagree (if I can do that) all at the same time! :) I agree that we need to have a logical understanding of our faith and practice and what is what with the God of the universe. At the same time, there is no greater mystery then the God of the universe and to create logical constructs all around the God of the universe would be to try to explain away the great mystery that is Jesus Christ. Faith certainly isn't factless, but faith certainly is believing things that are unseen. I honestly think that the enlightenment wasn't all that great for the Christ follower because now it is demanded that we 'explain' all of the things that are unexplainable in scripture.

If your friend needs logic, I think it is our duty as Christ followers to know and give logic, but the reality is that we can get so swept up in that that it becomes consuming and so 'measured' that it gets in the way of faith in practice.

Your comment on examination of the faith is a great one. We need to do so, indeed!

Just my thoughts. Good, challenging article, especially as it relates to sharing the gospel with those far from God. Thanks man!

Not certain what "witnessing"

Not certain what "witnessing" was truly being accomplished at a pub/bar. Intellectual debates will never end well. The conversation should always be turned to personal examination from the point of conscience. Do you all follow the Law (Ten Commandments)? If not, you all need to start from that point. From admission of being sinners it leads to the Gospel. The challenge is that people do not see themselves as sinners (or that bad of a sinner) when the Bible states "all have sinned and fallen short". Jesus did not come to discuss theology but to save sinners. That is and always will be the starting point to understanding God and the Gospel. Judgement Day will be just that - Judgement of sin, not of theology. The Bible is the history book of creation, fallen man, sin, forgiveness and how it will end. Very concise. I would encourage you to do more examining of what you truly believe, open the Word and start from there.

There are several passages of

There are several passages of scripture that come to mind when I read this post.

For the word of the cross is folly to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God.
1 Corinthians 1:18

So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ.
Romans 10:17

I think we struggle to try to get unbelievers to 'understand' but only God can do this. Only God can open the unbeliever's heart.

Pray that He does and allow Him to get the increase.

Hello My Dear Friends, Users

Hello My Dear Friends, Users Forum !

The Company In-Disguise . Com

Anonymous Internet Surfing, Anonymous Downloading-Uploading Torrent-P2P, Amonymous WiFI.
In-Disguise . Com - Fully Automatic and Anonymous VPN Service , you don’t have to waste time on:

1 - Search Supports if disconnected from a server, search for a standard installation “OpenVPN client”
spend time for installing downloaded configs to the program.
Subscribe to All Servers of Our Service for 9 Euro; 3 months = 20 Euro; 6 months = 35 Euro; 1 year = 55 Euro.

2 - Unique “VPN Client” is easy to install on all kinds of Operating Systems: MAC / Windows / Linux!!!
Will allow you to switch easily between the VPN servers in USA / DE / UK / IT / NL / LU / EG / PA / RO / MY Continuing
Types of VPN connections included in a single subscription - DoubleVPN and OpenVPN.

3 - Company Takes All Kinds Of Payments in Full Auto Mode!
WebMoney / Visa / Master Card / PayPal / Liberty Reserve / BitCoin / SMS and many others.

Our VPN Service Is Here!

in-disguise . com

Sincerely, Your Anonymous VPN Service : In-Disguise . Com

Hello My Dear Friends, Users

Hello My Dear Friends, Users Forum !

The Company In-Disguise . Com

Anonymous Internet Surfing, Anonymous Downloading-Uploading Torrent-P2P, Amonymous WiFI.
In-Disguise . Com - Fully Automatic and Anonymous VPN Service , you don’t have to waste time on:

1 - Search Supports if disconnected from a server, search for a standard installation “OpenVPN client”
spend time for installing downloaded configs to the program.
Subscribe to All Servers of Our Service for 9 Euro; 3 months = 20 Euro; 6 months = 35 Euro; 1 year = 55 Euro.

2 - Unique “VPN Client” is easy to install on all kinds of Operating Systems: MAC / Windows / Linux!!!
Will allow you to switch easily between the VPN servers in USA / DE / UK / IT / NL / LU / EG / PA / RO / MY Continuing
Types of VPN connections included in a single subscription - DoubleVPN and OpenVPN.

3 - Company Takes All Kinds Of Payments in Full Auto Mode!
WebMoney / Visa / Master Card / PayPal / Liberty Reserve / BitCoin / SMS and many others.

Our VPN Service Is Here!

in-disguise . com

Sincerely, Your Anonymous VPN Service : In-Disguise . Com

Hello, Ray Gentry, I was

Hello,

Ray Gentry, I was looking at your post and thinking. Most people that don't know God simply just have not met or understood Him yet and don't want to look or feel stupid. It's important to get to the heart of the matter. It's not why the world doesn't choose to believe that matters or what the world says about Christ, it is what that particular person's reason is that he/she does not believe or accept the Gospel. The rest of the conversation is a wall to avoid dealing with this matter. You should always (every single time regarding every individual person/group) ask the Holy Spirit to lead and guide you on what you should say, do, etc. It's always different. God Bless you for your heart and attempt to reach others who desperately need Salvation before they die.

As for me, I heard God's voice at eight years old when He called me into the ministry. I've also heard His voice several times since and seen several miracles. It's not possible to convince me that God does not exist. I'd have better luck trying to convince you that you never had a great, great grandmother, lol.

Here's some basic witnessing ammo you may already know:
Atheist-does not believe in a higher power
Agnostic-does believe in a higher power, but is not sure it is God.

I haven't talked to any 'atheist' for more than five minutes who didn't admit that he/she was actually agnostic. The fact (logic) is, that out of 100% of knowledge in the universe, howuch do you think you have. Some people think I'm pretty smart (4.0, organized, etc,), but I would say that I may have .01% when you consider the amount of knowledge. How far is this star from that star-height, breadth, depth? I know that scientists can't create a piece of dirt for anything and if you could just make a machine that turns grass into milk (like the cow does), you'd be an instant billionaire. Is the cow smart? No, but his creator is brilliant. There are 40 billion nerve cells in the human eye alone. Do I believe an architect designed us and creation, most definitely. Most atheists realize very quick they're actually agnostic.

Now they need to understand that God is the creator. They need to know that although God is the creator, he desires a relationship with each and every person, including them. They also need to know about Adam and Eve and how because of them every person is born into sin and that the wages of sin is death. Thank God for His plan to send His only son Jesus to voluntarily give His sinless life on the cross for our sins, that we can be forgiven. Romans 8:9,10

Some people think they know God though they've never accepted Jesus. 1 John 2:23 shows that this is not possible, and if someone doesn't know that Jesus is the son of God, than they do not know Jesus. Personally, It was not hard for me to believe, especially with all the things I had seen and heard. As for your friend that considers himself an unbeliever because of logic, sadly it will not be an acceptable excuse. Romans 1:18-20 (I typically use the KJV for everything just so you know) explains that because of creation, men are without excuse. Another bit of logic is that we must die, it's coming sooner or later, Heaven or Hell, just as the Bible says. Hell is every bit of bad as the Bible describes.

Something else interesting is the phenomena of the Bible. It is not just merely written by men; it is God-breathed (2 Timothy 3:16) and from the outside it may seem that it contradicts itself at times, but the more and more you study it, the more you see how wonderfully complements itself. You can almost always find at least three Scripture ref's for any valid point. I can tell one person a sentence to pass along through ten people. It's always a word or two different or a different sentence altogether. One extreme phenomena of the Bible is that it was written over a time period of about 1600 years (1500 BC-100AD (approx, some people speculate on the dates of some books)) and it is remarkably accurate!! It is 98% with the 2% being slight word variations (nothing doctrinal). Now, that's an outstanding agreement between the 66 books that were written over a time span of approx 1600 years when I can't accurately pass a sentence across a room!

The real point is that everyone needs to come to know God and have a very personal relationship with him where they talk to Him all the time and read His word. All the other facts they can really explore later if they want, but they need that personal relationship with God. If they've never had it, they need it more than anything. Hope this information is useful to you or someone else. Thanks also to all the other people who helped answer by contributing your advice. God be with you all. (Hopefully I didn't make too many mistakes typing this in on my phone)

Glory to God in the Highest,

Rome

Hello, Ray Gentry, I was

Hello,

Ray Gentry, I was looking at your post and thinking. Most people that don't know God simply just have not met or understood Him yet and don't want to look or feel stupid. It's important to get to the heart of the matter. It's not why the world doesn't choose to believe that matters or what the world says about Christ, it is what that particular person's reason is that he/she does not believe or accept the Gospel. The rest of the conversation is a wall to avoid dealing with this matter. You should always (every single time regarding every individual person/group) ask the Holy Spirit to lead and guide you on what you should say, do, etc. It's always different. God Bless you for your heart and attempt to reach others who desperately need Salvation before they die.

As for me, I heard God's voice at eight years old when He called me into the ministry. I've also heard His voice several times since and seen several miracles. It's not possible to convince me that God does not exist. I'd have better luck trying to convince you that you never had a great, great grandmother, lol.

Here's some basic witnessing ammo you may already know:
Atheist-does not believe in a higher power
Agnostic-does believe in a higher power, but is not sure it is God.

I haven't talked to any 'atheist' for more than five minutes who didn't admit that he/she was actually agnostic. The fact (logic) is, that out of 100% of knowledge in the universe, howuch do you think you have. Some people think I'm pretty smart (4.0, organized, etc,), but I would say that I may have .01% when you consider the amount of knowledge. How far is this star from that star-height, breadth, depth? I know that scientists can't create a piece of dirt for anything and if you could just make a machine that turns grass into milk (like the cow does), you'd be an instant billionaire. Is the cow smart? No, but his creator is brilliant. There are 40 billion nerve cells in the human eye alone. Do I believe an architect designed us and creation, most definitely. Most atheists realize very quick they're actually agnostic.

Now they need to understand that God is the creator. They need to know that although God is the creator, he desires a relationship with each and every person, including them. They also need to know about Adam and Eve and how because of them every person is born into sin and that the wages of sin is death. Thank God for His plan to send His only son Jesus to voluntarily give His sinless life on the cross for our sins, that we can be forgiven. Romans 8:9,10

Some people think they know God though they've never accepted Jesus. 1 John 2:23 shows that this is not possible, and if someone doesn't know that Jesus is the son of God, than they do not know Jesus. Personally, It was not hard for me to believe, especially with all the things I had seen and heard. As for your friend that considers himself an unbeliever because of logic, sadly it will not be an acceptable excuse. Romans 1:18-20 (I typically use the KJV for everything just so you know) explains that because of creation, men are without excuse. Another bit of logic is that we must die, it's coming sooner or later, Heaven or Hell, just as the Bible says. Hell is every bit of bad as the Bible describes.

Something else interesting is the phenomena of the Bible. It is not just merely written by men; it is God-breathed (2 Timothy 3:16) and from the outside it may seem that it contradicts itself at times, but the more and more you study it, the more you see how wonderfully complements itself. You can almost always find at least three Scripture ref's for any valid point. I can tell one person a sentence to pass along through ten people. It's always a word or two different or a different sentence altogether. One extreme phenomena of the Bible is that it was written over a time period of about 1600 years (1500 BC-100AD (approx, some people speculate on the dates of some books)) and it is remarkably accurate!! It is 98% with the 2% being slight word variations (nothing doctrinal). Now, that's an outstanding agreement between the 66 books that were written over a time span of approx 1600 years when I can't accurately pass a sentence across a room!

The real point is that everyone needs to come to know God and have a very personal relationship with him where they talk to Him all the time and read His word. All the other facts they can really explore later if they want, but they need that personal relationship with God. If they've never had it, they need it more than anything. Hope this information is useful to you or someone else. Thanks also to all the other people who helped answer by contributing your advice. God be with you all. (Hopefully I didn't make too many mistakes typing this in on my phone)

Glory to God in the Highest,

Rome

Hello, Ray Gentry, I was

Hello,

Ray Gentry, I was looking at your post and thinking. Most people that don't know God simply just have not met or understood Him yet and don't want to look or feel stupid. It's important to get to the heart of the matter. It's not why the world doesn't choose to believe that matters or what the world says about Christ, it is what that particular person's reason is that he/she does not believe or accept the Gospel. The rest of the conversation is a wall to avoid dealing with this matter. You should always (every single time regarding every individual person/group) ask the Holy Spirit to lead and guide you on what you should say, do, etc. It's always different. God Bless you for your heart and attempt to reach others who desperately need Salvation before they die.

As for me, I heard God's voice at eight years old when He called me into the ministry. I've also heard His voice several times since and seen several miracles. It's not possible to convince me that God does not exist. I'd have better luck trying to convince you that you never had a great, great grandmother, lol.

Here's some basic witnessing ammo you may already know:
Atheist-does not believe in a higher power
Agnostic-does believe in a higher power, but is not sure it is God.

I haven't talked to any 'atheist' for more than five minutes who didn't admit that he/she was actually agnostic. The fact (logic) is, that out of 100% of knowledge in the universe, howuch do you think you have. Some people think I'm pretty smart (4.0, organized, etc,), but I would say that I may have .01% when you consider the amount of knowledge. How far is this star from that star-height, breadth, depth? I know that scientists can't create a piece of dirt for anything and if you could just make a machine that turns grass into milk (like the cow does), you'd be an instant billionaire. Is the cow smart? No, but his creator is brilliant. There are 40 billion nerve cells in the human eye alone. Do I believe an architect designed us and creation, most definitely. Most atheists realize very quick they're actually agnostic.

Now they need to understand that God is the creator. They need to know that although God is the creator, he desires a relationship with each and every person, including them. They also need to know about Adam and Eve and how because of them every person is born into sin and that the wages of sin is death. Thank God for His plan to send His only son Jesus to voluntarily give His sinless life on the cross for our sins, that we can be forgiven. Romans 8:9,10

Some people think they know God though they've never accepted Jesus. 1 John 2:23 shows that this is not possible, and if someone doesn't know that Jesus is the son of God, than they do not know Jesus. Personally, It was not hard for me to believe, especially with all the things I had seen and heard. As for your friend that considers himself an unbeliever because of logic, sadly it will not be an acceptable excuse. Romans 1:18-20 (I typically use the KJV for everything just so you know) explains that because of creation, men are without excuse. Another bit of logic is that we must die, it's coming sooner or later, Heaven or Hell, just as the Bible says. Hell is every bit of bad as the Bible describes.

Something else interesting is the phenomena of the Bible. It is not just merely written by men; it is God-breathed (2 Timothy 3:16) and from the outside it may seem that it contradicts itself at times, but the more and more you study it, the more you see how wonderfully complements itself. You can almost always find at least three Scripture ref's for any valid point. I can tell one person a sentence to pass along through ten people. It's always a word or two different or a different sentence altogether. One extreme phenomena of the Bible is that it was written over a time period of about 1600 years (1500 BC-100AD (approx, some people speculate on the dates of some books)) and it is remarkably accurate!! It is 98% with the 2% being slight word variations (nothing doctrinal). Now, that's an outstanding agreement between the 66 books that were written over a time span of approx 1600 years when I can't accurately pass a sentence across a room!

The real point is that everyone needs to come to know God and have a very personal relationship with him where they talk to Him all the time and read His word. All the other facts they can really explore later if they want, but they need that personal relationship with God. If they've never had it, they need it more than anything. Hope this information is useful to you or someone else. Thanks also to all the other people who helped answer by contributing your advice. God be with you all. (Hopefully I didn't make too many mistakes typing this in on my phone)

Glory to God in the Highest,

Rome

Hello, Ray Gentry, I was

Hello,

Ray Gentry, I was looking at your post and thinking. Most people that don't know God simply just have not met or understood Him yet and don't want to look or feel stupid. It's important to get to the heart of the matter. It's not why the world doesn't choose to believe that matters or what the world says about Christ, it is what that particular person's reason is that he/she does not believe or accept the Gospel. The rest of the conversation is a wall to avoid dealing with this matter. You should always (every single time regarding every individual person/group) ask the Holy Spirit to lead and guide you on what you should say, do, etc. It's always different. God Bless you for your heart and attempt to reach others who desperately need Salvation before they die.

As for me, I heard God's voice at eight years old when He called me into the ministry. I've also heard His voice several times since and seen several miracles. It's not possible to convince me that God does not exist. I'd have better luck trying to convince you that you never had a great, great grandmother, lol.

Here's some basic witnessing ammo you may already know:
Atheist-does not believe in a higher power
Agnostic-does believe in a higher power, but is not sure it is God.

I haven't talked to any 'atheist' for more than five minutes who didn't admit that he/she was actually agnostic. The fact (logic) is, that out of 100% of knowledge in the universe, howuch do you think you have. Some people think I'm pretty smart (4.0, organized, etc,), but I would say that I may have .01% when you consider the amount of knowledge. How far is this star from that star-height, breadth, depth? I know that scientists can't create a piece of dirt for anything and if you could just make a machine that turns grass into milk (like the cow does), you'd be an instant billionaire. Is the cow smart? No, but his creator is brilliant. There are 40 billion nerve cells in the human eye alone. Do I believe an architect designed us and creation, most definitely. Most atheists realize very quick they're actually agnostic.

Now they need to understand that God is the creator. They need to know that although God is the creator, he desires a relationship with each and every person, including them. They also need to know about Adam and Eve and how because of them every person is born into sin and that the wages of sin is death. Thank God for His plan to send His only son Jesus to voluntarily give His sinless life on the cross for our sins, that we can be forgiven. Romans 8:9,10

Some people think they know God though they've never accepted Jesus. 1 John 2:23 shows that this is not possible, and if someone doesn't know that Jesus is the son of God, than they do not know Jesus. Personally, It was not hard for me to believe, especially with all the things I had seen and heard. As for your friend that considers himself an unbeliever because of logic, sadly it will not be an acceptable excuse. Romans 1:18-20 (I typically use the KJV for everything just so you know) explains that because of creation, men are without excuse. Another bit of logic is that we must die, it's coming sooner or later, Heaven or Hell, just as the Bible says. Hell is every bit of bad as the Bible describes.

Something else interesting is the phenomena of the Bible. It is not just merely written by men; it is God-breathed (2 Timothy 3:16) and from the outside it may seem that it contradicts itself at times, but the more and more you study it, the more you see how wonderfully complements itself. You can almost always find at least three Scripture ref's for any valid point. I can tell one person a sentence to pass along through ten people. It's always a word or two different or a different sentence altogether. One extreme phenomena of the Bible is that it was written over a time period of about 1600 years (1500 BC-100AD (approx, some people speculate on the dates of some books)) and it is remarkably accurate!! It is 98% with the 2% being slight word variations (nothing doctrinal). Now, that's an outstanding agreement between the 66 books that were written over a time span of approx 1600 years when I can't accurately pass a sentence across a room!

The real point is that everyone needs to come to know God and have a very personal relationship with him where they talk to Him all the time and read His word. All the other facts they can really explore later if they want, but they need that personal relationship with God. If they've never had it, they need it more than anything. Hope this information is useful to you or someone else. Thanks also to all the other people who helped answer by contributing your advice. God be with you all. (Hopefully I didn't make too many mistakes typing this in on my phone)

Glory to God in the Highest,

Rome

I want to wish you good luck

I want to wish you good luck and all the best

I want to wish you good luck

I want to wish you good luck and all the best

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.